I also have a 5 page review currently 95% completed pending my last stint with the game. I was also troubled to see that Aquaria isn't listed on Metacritic. I have virtually no faith left in games journalism these days, barring sites that follow the indy scene, and my own site (
www.overwritten.net) seems to have hit a permanent work lagspike that will last from now until doomsday, but I couldn't help myself. The game deserves more attention than it's going to get, and I wanted to at least do what I could despite not having a real portal to post it on (this makes me sad... anybody want to pay me for some freelance work?).
Let's hope we can get the game even more exposure.